Copycat Jersey Mike’s Sub

It seems that there is a sub shop on every corner no matter where you go. When we do grab a sub, it’s Jersey Mike’s. We love the bread, the ratio of ingredients, oil and vinegar, and seasonings. We don’t eat out often, so when we get a craving for a sub we make a copycat of Jersey Mike’s sub at home.
Copycat Jersey Mike's Sub

The keys to making a good copycat of Jersey Mike’s sub are the right oil ratio (3 parts canola oil and 1 part olive oil) and the red wine vinegar (5% diluted). After that, you can do whatever you want, pretty much. We like ours “Mike’s Way”, with tomato, lettuce, onion, and of course oregano and salt. It’s a combination that always works.

Also checkout my copycat of one of my all-time favorite restaurant sandwiches, Subway’s Italian BMT, and my copycat of Quizno’s Italian Sub and of course, my copycat Firehouse Subs Battalion Chief sub too! And you don’t have to make a copycat of a chain restaurant sandwich to have a great lunch, either. Try my house sub too!

Copycat Jersey Mike's Sub

Course Main
Cuisine American
Prep Time 15 minutes
Servings 4 servings
Author Mike

Ingredients

For the sandwich

  • 2 loaves French bread sliced horizontally
  • 1/2 head iceberg lettuce shredded
  • 1 pound thin sliced deli sandwich meat
  • 2 large tomatoes sliced
  • 1 large sweet onion sliced
  • 2 teaspoons dried oregano more or less, to taste, crushed
  • 2 teaspoons kosher salt more or less, to taste
  • red wine vinegar diluted to 5%, see note
  • 3 tablespoons canola oil
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil

Instructions

  • Assemble the sandwich by dividing the meat between the bread halves.
  • Add the tomato and onion slices. Top with a few good handfuls of the lettuce.
  • Sprinkle the sandwiches with the red wine vinegar. Don't be shy with it.
  • Combine the canola and olive oils and sprinkle over the sandwiches. More is better, in my opinion.
  • Finally, sprinkle tops with the oregano and salt. Add the top halves of the bread, slice in half in the middle. Serve.

Notes

Note: The red wine vinegar you use should be dilute to 5%. I checked a few of the bottles available at our local grocery store and all were 5%, so I did not need to dilute the vinegar any further.

4 thoughts on “Copycat Jersey Mike’s Sub

  1. Wow… This recipe was amazing…! So juicy and tasty- I was even able to transfer it from your website to my phone using the MyCookbook web tool. Jersey Mikes is one of my favorite places to go. I go several times a month and buy the turkey or tuna sub. Once a month I treat myself to a philly cheese steak from there. Your recipe is just like Jersey Mike’s-if not much better. Doing it this way will save me a lot of money too. I still will go once a month for my philly cheese steak, but I think I will make the turkey sub at home 🙂 I always advise Jersey Mikes to put extra oregano and vinegar on my sub. Very nice to be able to put as much as I want on it at home.

    May I suggest a recipe for Firehouse Subs (turkey)-fully involved? That sandwich may be hard to do-just a though. Thanks so much. I can’t wait to try your other subs.

  2. Also, I added provolone cheese and used Publix hoagie bread as they did not have french bread at the time. The hoagie bread was very soft and tasty, so that is a good choice also.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.